Pros and Cons of Hospital Birth
| Positive |
Negative |
| Availability of latest technology to assist in the birth process | "Active Management of Labor" rather than respect for the natural birth process. The birth process is regulated from start to finish using the latest technology |
| Availability of a variety of anesthesia | Higher rate of electronic fetal monitoring is associated with higher rate of forceps delivery, episiotomy, and ceasarean section |
| 8 Availability of trained medical personnel 8 |
Doctor and hospital assume responsibility for safe birth |
| Availability of insurance coverage | Restriction of freedom to have food and drink, move into comfortable positions, and be in control of your birth experience |
| Hospital takes care of birth certificate | Hospital environment generally produces more anxiety which interferes with labor |
| 8 | Many hospitals do not allow midwives to attend births, so choice of caregiver is limited to doctors |
| 8 | Without insurance coverage, doctor and hospital fees are very expensive |
| 8 | Medical professionals rarely trust the mother's own evaluation of her condition and rely totally on technology to help make decisions |
| 8 | Environment is sterile, cold, uninviting |
| 88 | Continuity of the birth experience is interrupted when the mother must move to the delivery room |
| 8 | Spirituality of the birth experience is not a priority |
| 8 | Medical professionals are trained in how to identify and treat abnormalities, not how to recognize and facilitate normal birth, few have been trained to sit back, observe, and do nothing |
| 8 | Many tests and procedures are performed to avoid malpractice, not because you really need them |
| 8 | Some hospitals will not allow children to be present during birth |
| 8 | Mother and baby are often separated after birth for a period of 2 to 12 hours |
| 8 | Hospitals contain many kinds of dangerous germs not present in a home environment |
| 8 | Sugar water or formula is often given to infants in the newborn nursery even if parents request that baby be breastfed only |
| 8 | Newborn nurseries are rarely able to provide the constant skin-to-skin contact infants need to receive from their mothers |
Back to The Online Childbirth Class
Back to the Unhindered Living Knowledge Collection
See
The Pros and Cons of Home Birth
Copyright 2001-9
Judie C. Snelson and The Center for Unhindered Living
For more
education
about natural birth and pregnancy
Visit the Products for Unhindered Pregnancy
and Birth